What the calculator is actually doing
Kakeibo (家計簿, household ledger) does not divide income into percentages. It sets an order. First you write down what you have. Then you decide what you would like to save, and you take it out before anything else. Only the remainder gets divided, and it gets divided into four envelopes rather than the twenty categories a banking app would offer you.
So the arithmetic above runs in that order. Your savings promise leaves first. Your fixed Survival costs come out next, because they are already committed and pretending otherwise helps nobody. What remains is split between Optional, Culture and Extra, and those three are where a month is actually won or lost.
