A category list long enough to be accurate is too long to be used.
Four envelopes, not twenty categories
Banking apps sort spending into dozens of categories automatically, and the result is a pie chart nobody acts on. Kakeibo goes the other way. Four envelopes is few enough to hold in your head at the counter, which is the moment the decision is actually made, and the sorting is done by you rather than by a merchant code that thinks your supermarket lunch was groceries.
The categories are also chosen to make one specific tradeoff visible. Culture sits apart from Optional so that books, courses and exhibitions are not quietly cut alongside impulse shopping. That separation is the method taking a position: the first thing to go should not be the thing that improves you.
